Sag Harbor Inn, Sag Harbor ➤ Reviews, Rooms & Prices 2025

Book on our site

Up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

45 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, New York, United States

The Sag Harbor Inn offers luxury accommodations in a 42-room boutique setting overlooking the harbor. It features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, complimentary breakfast, and modern amenities, making it suitable for family gatherings, romantic getaways, or corporate retreats.

Rooms & Amenities

Rooms at the Sag Harbor Inn are fully renovated and feature complimentary Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and private climate control. Guests can enjoy Simmons Beautyrest mattresses, refrigerators, and daily housekeeping services. Some rooms include additional amenities such as separate dressing areas and USB charging stations.

Dining & Nearby Options

Dining options at the Sag Harbor Inn include access to numerous restaurants within walking distance, featuring a range of international cuisines, such as seafood and Italian. Popular local restaurants like The Beacon and Lulu Kitchen & Bar are just a short stroll away. The hotel also offers a complimentary breakfast daily.

Leisure & Entertainment

The Sag Harbor Inn provides a variety of leisure opportunities, including a seasonal outdoor pool and easy access to local beaches, hiking trails, and wineries. Guests can bike or drive to nearby attractions and enjoy the live theatre and international events that Sag Harbor hosts. The hotel is also a great site for small meetings and gatherings with harbor views.

Services & Local Area

With 24/7 front desk service, complimentary private parking, and bicycle storage, the Sag Harbor Inn caters to various guest needs. The hotel is ADA approved and has convenient access routes. Additionally, it is positioned within short distances of notable landmarks, including the Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum and Grenning Gallery.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

1st floor Harbor Queen Bed

Max:

2 persons

36 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Heating

Bathtub

room details

Check Prices

2nd floor Harbor Queen Bed

Max:

2 persons

36 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Heating

Bathtub

room details

Check Prices

2nd floor Harbor 2 Double Beds

Max:

2 persons

36 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Heating

Bathtub

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A list of all available modes of transport

City Centre

Sag Harbor900 m

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 80.9 km

Republic (FRG) 109.2 km

Train

Southampton 13.9 km

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Spacious and Spotless

“My room was impressively large and impeccably clean, making my stay incredibly comfortable and relaxing.” view full review

Breakfast with a View

“Enjoying breakfast with a stunning ocean view was the highlight of my mornings, a perfect way to start the day.” view full review

Personalized Touch

“Returning to the Sag Inn was good, especially when the manager recognized me, making it feel like a home away from home.” view full review

Cozy Living Space

“The living area of my suite was not only comfortable but also beautifully designed, perfect for unwinding after a long day.” view full review

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi
Free parking
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
24-hour security
Luggage storage
Allergy-free rooms
Lift
Vending machines
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers
Key access

Services

Housekeeping

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Cots

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Sun loungers
Leisure/ TV room
Public Bath
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Patio
Garden furniture

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

45 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, New York, United States

Map view

45 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, New York, United States

City landmarks

Harbour

Sag Harbor

850 m

Church

First Presbyterian Old Whalers Church

770 m

Park

Sag Harbor Marine Park

970 m

Gallery

Monika Olko Gallery

600 m

Gallery

Grenning Gallery

730 m

114 Division St

Sage Street Antiques

750 m

Gallery

Tulla Booth Gallery

740 m

Gallery

Romany Kramoris Gallery

800 m

Mashashimuet Park

1.4 km

Beach

Haven's Beach

1.8 km

Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge

3.3 km

Barcelona Neck Road

Sag Harbor Golf Course

3.4 km

Beach

Foster Memorial Town Beach

4.2 km

335 Ferry Rd

North Haven Village Park

3.5 km

1061 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike

Long Pond Greenbelt Nature Center

3.8 km

Lake

Trout Pond Park

4.2 km

376 Bridgehampton/Sag Harbor Tpke

Children's Museum of The East End

4.8 km

554 NY-114

Northwest Woods Trails

5.0 km

Museum

South Fork Natural History Museum and Nature Center

5.9 km

Nearby

Museum

Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum

410 m

Main and Garden Street

Custom House Museum

430 m

8 Wharf St

The Windmill

460 m

Restaurants

Sag Harbor Baking Company

900 m

51 Division St

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

74%

liked the hotel and would stay again

beautiful view

directly across from yacht club

tired rooms

old patio furniture

7.4/10

Very good

Rooms

7.6

Location

8.6

Service

6.8

Dining

7.2

Thomas

United States, March 2024

9.0/10

I absolutely loved my stay at this hotel! The location is superb, right across from the harbor and within walking distance to the town's best restaurants. The rooms were not just clean but also had everything I needed for a comfortable stay. The service was top-notch, with friendly and accommodating staff. The only downside might be the slightly inflated prices, but considering the prime location, it's worth the extra bucks.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms across the elevator were clean and had everything needed. They are definitely worth the extra bucks.

Service

8.0

The housekeeping staff was absolutely nice and helpful.

Location

10.0

The hotel's ideal location, directly across from a yacht club in the harbor, allowed me to walk to town with an abundance of excellent restaurants.

Dining

9.0

The dining experience in the comfortable, yet chicly decorated lounge was quick and easy, continental style. The breakfast was complete with yogurt, cereal, muffins, bagels, juice, and coffee.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities were upscale and offered all the amenities one could need during their stay.

Rudy

United States, November 2023

7.0/10

My stay at the hotel was a mixed experience. The room, while clean and comfortable, felt a bit dated, but the view of the water was lovely. The service started off friendly but became less accommodating when I raised some concerns. The location was ideal for exploring the town, with plenty of dining options within walking distance. The dining experience was satisfactory, although the breakfast could have offered more variety. The overall facilities were decent, but some areas needed maintenance.

Rooms

7.0

My room was a bit dated but clean and comfortable with a nice view of the water.

Service

6.0

The service initially started off friendly and helpful but became less accommodating later.

Location

8.0

The location was perfect for exploring the town with many restaurants within walking distance.

Dining

7.0

The dining experience was satisfactory, but the breakfast could have had more variety.

Facilities

7.0

The facilities were decent but in need of some maintenance.

Terry

United States, October 2023

7.2/10

I truly enjoyed my stay at this hotel. The rooms were spacious and adequate, although they felt a bit tired. The view overlooking the water from the deck with a queen bed was lovely. The breakfast was good, especially with the extra light coming through the additional window in the room.

Rooms

7.0

The rooms were spacious and adequate, but felt a bit tired. The extra window provided good light and the view overlooking the water from the deck with a queen bed was beautiful.

Service

7.0

The service at the breakfast room was very accommodating. However, there was a moment when the staff seemed a bit arrogant when I tried to discuss my dissatisfactions. Overall, they were friendly and accommodating.

Location

9.0

The location was ideal as it is directly across from a yacht club in the harbor. It allowed us to walk to town with a great selection of excellent restaurants. For me, the marine location was perfect.

Dining

7.0

The breakfast was excellent, offering yogurt, cereal, muffins, bagels, juice, and coffee. However, it seemed to be reduced to a few packages of cereal, milk, cheap OJ, and weak coffee. Given the construction of a new hotel nearby, I expected more variety to compete better.

Facilities

6.0

The facilities were decent, but I did notice the old patio furniture. Overall, they were adequate for the marine location.

beautiful view

tired rooms

Fred

United States, September 2023

7.6/10

My stay at the hotel was a mix of highs and lows. While my water view room gave me a lovely sight of the harbor, the room itself was a bit worn out with threadbare furniture and some maintenance issues like paint needed on the terrace and bugs in the bathroom. However, the room was spacious, clean, and equipped with all the necessary amenities like a refrigerator and microwave.

Rooms

7.0

The room provided a beautiful view of the water, but was in need of some updates and maintenance.

Service

8.0

The service was laid back and friendly, though there were moments where it felt like the staff were not fully attentive.

Location

9.0

The location was ideal, directly across from the harbor and close to the town for convenience. The view of the water and boats from the breakfast area was a definite highlight.

Dining

7.0

The breakfast offered was simple but sufficient to start the day, with a continental style that was quick and easy to access.

Facilities

7.0

The facilities were average, but the view of the harbor and the proximity to the yacht club added a nice touch to the overall experience.

Charles

United States, August 2023

6.6/10

My stay at the hotel was overall pleasant. The rooms were clean, spacious, and well-equipped with amenities like a refrigerator and microwave. The bed was comfortable, and I enjoyed the nice view of the harbor. However, the service was lacking, with unhelpful and somewhat arrogant staff. The location was convenient, close to town and with a good view of the water, but the decor was uninspiring. The dining experience was basic but satisfactory, and the facilities were decent.

Rooms

8.0

The room I stayed in was roomy with a comfortable bed, couch, and a view of the harbor. It was well-appointed with a King size bed, flatscreen cable TV, and a cozy sitting area.

Service

5.0

The staff at the hotel wasn't very friendly. They seemed indifferent and unfriendly during our interactions.

Location

7.0

The location of the hotel was ideal, directly across from a yacht club in the harbor, offering a great view of the water and close proximity to restaurants and shopping.

Dining

6.0

The dining options were basic but served the purpose. A quick continental-style breakfast with yogurt, cereal, muffins, and coffee helped start the day.

Facilities

7.0

The hotel facilities were adequate for my stay. Nothing extravagant but met my needs.

clean

unfriendly staff